One of the more unusual aspects of the story of Italian Hall is that there is still disagreement as to how many people perished on Christmas Eve 1913. It seems odd to us – today – that such a thing could be unclear: after all, how could something so important NOT be carved in stone?
There are several issues that need to be addressed here, many of which are influenced by how different things were back then. First, the scene itself was confusing. Several thousand people were on the scene as the victims (and survivors) were pulled from the stairwell. Stories circulated that as many as 80 people had been killed. In fact, the headline of the Daily Mining Gazette gave the figure of 80 immediately after the event.

On the other hand, as Peggy Germain has pointed out (in her "False Alarm") – there were 73 death certificates issued by the Coroner which listed the Hall as the place of death. Since the certificates are numbered, she could show us that the one before the first and the one after the 73rd were unrelated to the Hall. To many (myself included), that is the strongest evidence that the number is, and should be, 73.
Of course, there are arguments that can be made for other numbers. In my book I explore this in much greater depth. For instance, in the days leading up to the funerals for the victims, the local papers quoted the numbers of victims being handled by each of the local funeral homes. Presumably, they got those numbers from the homes themselves. What did those numbers add up to? 79. Is it possible that the homes were mistaken about how many bodies they were handling? It seems impossible, or at least highly unlikely.
And then, several histories of the area were written, giving the number as 74. Often, they list among their dead people who were known to have survived. Confusion and mystery always want to swirl around the story of the Italian Hall -- I think however that a close examination of the facts and evidence allows us to get to the truth.